5 Best Butt Plugs, According to Customer Feedback

Butt plugs come in all shapes and sizes. I love ‘em, you love ‘em, hell I bet there is a drag queen out there who loves them so much she’ll wear one on stage!

So, how do you find the butt plugs that everyone’s raving about? You could sift through hours and hours of paid content that endorses some of these products. You’ll even find gay pornstars behind some of these back-door stuffers. There is an insane number of butt plugs out there, it’s hard to know where to start.

These toys are to fill you back door with intense pleasure, but you still have to find the right one for you. Plus, you want to avoid any mediocre products or ones that give off the funk from low manufacturing standards. I got you, sis!

When you’re in the market for the best butt plugs, you wanna know from the at-home users like you! Not some power-bottom with a more-tolerant-than-most booty. You want to hear from guys like you, gay dudes who buy toys online.

In case you were wondering, this list will entirely consist of butt plugs. These are toys for beginners to expert plug enthusiast, and maybe even a treat! 

Best butt plugs for beginners

1. Colt Anal Trainer Kit

This set has to make this list. Anal trainer kits are an amazing purchase for a beginner butt play explorer. They allow you to gradually work up to a more average size, but they still have use even after your hole is used to plugs. This set includes two smaller plugs and an above average one for you to explore anal stretching with. If you think you’d be interested in more than just getting your toes wet, a trainer kit like this one is the way to go.

You’ll notice immediately that they vary a good deal in size, this is perfect for a newbie! You have the perfect sizes to practice with and one that will give you a good stretch. This set even increases in the shaft girth to give you the full benefits of butt plugs. You’ll notice almost immediately that with just using it once or twice makes bottoming sooooo much easier! So, if you find yourself getting really tight between fucks or just want to loosen up a little, you’ve got options with this set!

Later on, you’ll benefit from having multiple sizes! If you like to top and enjoy some butt play, then you should try wearing a butt plug while fucking your man. I promise you won’t regret it! You’ll have one of the most intense orgasms of your life. This is because the toy is massaging your prostate every time you thrust into his booty. You’ll notice a bigger, more powerful cumshot too! So, you really shouldn’t withhold that experience from yourself.

2. VeDO Rio Anal Vibe

If you’re looking for powerful toys, VeDO is a good place to start! This beginner-friendly anal vibrator is perfect for exploring your back door because it’s waterproof! You can loosen up with a hot shower and test this bad boy out. The tapered design makes insertion a breeze, you don’t have to worry about working past a big bulge or head. The ultra-smooth silicone slicks up with just drops of lube ensuring you have the best possible ride!

This toy’s powerful vibrations don’t have to be just for your hole either! Get creative and make use of this toy’s two hours of battery life to pleasure yourself to an insane climax. Press Rio against your perineum (your taint - the area between your balls and anus) to thrill your prostate and nerves with waves of pleasure. You can even use it for some unique nipple play and other BDSM-style teasing. You can even rub your cock and balls with this toy to enjoy the vibrations another way.

Our customers love this toy for a beginner! Plus, the powerful vibrations make it an awesome toy for anyone looking to enjoy some anal play. The size is absolutely perfect to hit your p-spot every time and enjoy the thrill-ride that is a prostate orgasm! Seriously, between the vibrations and pin-point design of this toy, you’ll be able to accurately hit the pleasure button inside your hole and never look back!

Best unique butt plug

3. TitanMen The Rumpy

The Rumpy from TitanMen takes the gold medal for a unique butt plug. The cock-head tip combined with the giant bulb on the same shaft set this toy apart from any other. Just like classic butt plugs, once this toy is past your entrance it stays locked in place with the flared base and bulb. It’s made of a flexible PVC material to ensure any time you’re using this time that you don’t feel any discomfort.

The real selling point of this toy is the phallic head that’s complete with glans and all. This toy gives you an almost double-beaded experience. After the head passes through your entrance you have the girth bulb to get in. It comfortably bends and conforms to fit the best way inside you, meaning you’re always in for a great experience. Use a few drops of lube for even better anal play! The matte material only needs a little lube to make insertion a breeze.

Users really dig the double bubble feature; it makes inserting the toy a thrill of its own. There’s nothing else really close to it on the market! Anal beads are either bigger or there are more than two of them, and other plugs are usually a tapered design. Even your hole will be able to tell this toy apart from your others. 

Best intense butt plug

4. Colt XXL Pumper Plug

Now, this toy is no joke. The Colt XXL Pumper Plug will fill you up like no dildo or cock ever could. It already starts out the size of an above-average specimen of man-meat measuring at six inches. He’s got girth too, starting at 1.75-inches wide. Inserting this toy is already work for seasoned bottoms, so prepare for a thrill when you start pumping it up. If you’ve never had an inflatable anal toy, then this is going to give your ass an insane new experience.

One use just isn’t enough! The immense feeling of fullness when using this toy can’t be compared to a basic dong or even other butt plugs. You can basically ride your way by varying how many times you pump to have more or less pressure. Each pump adds to the firmness and girth of this toy which means it can offer relentless pleasure. Seriously, the first time I used this inflatable butt plug my hole felt like it was used for days! I was basically horny for a week straight just because of that night.

Our customers love the absolutely stuffed to the rim feeling you get with this toy. Being made by Colt, you know you’re in for a good toy. The materials are durable and hold up to regular use. Make sure you’ve got lots of lube on hand, this guy needs to be slicked up for the best ride. You’ll want a high-quality lube that will last a long time because you’ll want to sit on this plug all night long. I’d go with an intense anal play favourite like Boy Butter.

Best high-tech butt plug

5. We-Vibe Ditto - Vibrating Butt PLug

Half the gay community started up an OnlyFans during quarantine and here’s a companion toy to on up your competition! This toy can be controlled via an app from basically anywhere. You can see how this might give your private clients an enhanced experience. This high-tech butt plug still comes with a remote for easy control, but the app is the big selling point. The vibrations and waves of pleasure you feel can be completely customized and controlled via the app or a lucky fellow.

If you’re quarantining away from your regular fuck buddy, you can give him control of the app to tease your hole as you go through your day. You can even give access to random guys off hookup apps for that stranger thrill! Even if you’re in a monogamous relationship, you two can see how long you can tease before one of you begs for cock! It’s easy to see why our customers love this butt plug, it’s so versatile you can use it so many different ways.

Our customers love how powerful the vibrations are. They also love that it’s the perfect size for on the go pleasure. It’s super discreet and quiet, so you won’t have to worry about any curious onlookers. That is if you can resist moaning from pleasure! Seriously, wear this toy on a date with your man and see how long you can go without squirming from the insane pleasure in your hole! We went out for ramen and I surprised my man with the app on my phone. You should’ve seen his grin all night as he knew he was winding me up!

That’s it, that’s the list of our best butt plugs according to customer feedback! These are some really intense toys, but also some great ones for the beginning stages of butt play. You won’t regret picking one of these up!